[Verse 1] You in my phone glow, thumb on your name Same little heartbeat, never quite the same I keep your voice in the back of my mind Like a half-finished song I can't leave behind Your hoodie on my chair, your scent in the seam Old little memories moving like steam I act like I'm fine, but you know the truth Every slow night brings me back to you [Pre-Chorus] And I try to let it fade But it pulls me closer Every time the rain comes down It says your name in slow motion [Chorus] Moonlit replay, replay You keep coming back to me Moonlit replay, replay Like a sweet little memory If I call, would you stay? Or slip away, slip away? Moonlit replay, replay Don't let this feeling fade [Verse 2] We had our moments, soft on the edge Barefoot honesty, sitting on the bed Your laugh in my chest, your tears in my palm Even the quiet used to feel like a song Now I'm in traffic with your shadow on Head full of maybe and what went wrong But I still smile when I see that sky 'Cause it looks like the way you used to light my life [Pre-Chorus] And I try to let it fade But it pulls me closer Every time the rain comes down It says your name in slow motion [Chorus] Moonlit replay, replay You keep coming back to me Moonlit replay, replay Like a sweet little memory If I call, would you stay? Or slip away, slip away? Moonlit replay, replay Don't let this feeling fade [Bridge] If you feel it too, say something Don't leave me here with just these echoes I could love you through the silence I could meet you where the moon goes [Final Chorus] Moonlit replay, replay You keep coming back to me Moonlit replay, replay Like a sweet little memory If I call, would you stay? Or slip away, slip away? Moonlit replay, replay Don't let this feeling fade